10 Best 4-Slice Toasters (Reviewed)

Making the perfect piece of toast is a feat for the few. Even if you get it right once, it’s almost impossible to consistently reach that crispy exterior with the hot soft interior, unless you have the best 4-slice toaster. 

Truth be told, toasters are quite simple machines. However, the market is chock-full of various models, so it’s not easy to find the one that suits your needs perfectly. That’s why we created a list of the most reliable, state-of-the-art, best double toasters available on the market.

Top Rated 4-Slice Toasters

Best Overall

Cuisinart CPT-435 Stainless Steel

Cuisinart CPT-435 Stainless Steel
  • Trusted brand – Cusinart Toasters
  • High-quality, durable stainless steel
  • Multiple toasting functions / displays

 

Premium Choice

Dualit 47160 NewGen Toaster

Dualit 47160 NewGen Toaster
  • Control each slot individually
  • Mechanical timer
  • Beautiful retro design
Best Budget

BLACK+DECKER, Stainless Steel (T4030)

BLACK+DECKER, Stainless Steel (T4030)
  • Affordable
  • Stainless steel body
  • Extra-wide 1.5-inch slots

We Also Recommend

  1. Easy to Use: Kitchenaid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice Toaster
  2. Commercial Grade: Dualit 46555 4-Slice Design Series Toaster
  3. Best Basic Design: Sencor STS6076GD
  4. Best Compact: Cuisinart CPT-142 Compact
  5. Best Long Slot: Smeg TSF02RDUS 50’s Retro Style
  6. Best High Tech: Cuisinart CPT-440 Leverless
  7. Great Option: Oster TSSTTRWF4S-SHP 4-Slice Toaster

Best 4-Slice Toaster Product Reviews

When it comes to technology, there are some amazing new engineering add-ons in the world of toasters. We’ll review features you never knew you needed!

However, imagine this situation: You’re someone who loves bread! You eat sliced bread, bagels, artisan bread, crumpets, British muffins, and more. They all want equal respect, but how do you manage to toast each one to perfection?

For those with a family, you may need to push out four or more slices of toast (possibly of more than one variety). Add to this the eggs on the pan, the coffee in the percolator. I hope you have a streamlined master kitchen fit for Gordon Ramsey. But stay tuned, because we have the toaster to solve your problems!

So, what are the top 4-slice toasters on the market today? Have you considered a long slot? What makes a toaster good? Can the best cheap 4-slice toaster replace a high-end model? Find the answers to all of these questions (and more) down below.

Best Overall
Cuisinart CPT-435 Countdown

Cuisinart CPT-435 Countdown

This Cuisinart CPT-435 is a kitchen appliance you’ll be glad you have. That’s exactly why we named it the best 4-slice toaster! This device provides you with four 1 ½” wide toasting slots for toasting anything from bread to English muffins, bagels and buns too.

Cuisinart offers a great defrosting method, useful for frozen waffles and the like. It will reheat toast without burning it. The heating options allow you to reduce the heat on uncut bagel sides and distribute heat based on shade.

Here’s what I like:

  • Extra-wide slots at 1.5”
  • Two LCD displays show shade control & countdown timer
  • Includes the bagel, defrost, and reheat function

The bad sides:

  • This model sometimes toasts unevenly, making the top darker than the bottom of the slice

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 12.6 x 12.3 x 9 inches
  • Weight: 7.1 pounds
  • Warranty: 3 years
Premium Choice
Dualit NewGen Toaster (47160)

Dualit NewGen Toaster (47160)

The 4-slot NewGen toaster is one of the most versatile toasters I review here and a personal favorite. This toaster was hand-assembled in the UK. Many know the Dualit brand, which has a long tradition of high-quality kitchen appliances. The NewGen comes in a variety of colors and a classic, retro design.

This model is built for commercial as well as residential use, so be assured, this is a durable machine. It comes with a slot selector control and a shade selection for each slot. Each slice can be adjusted to user preference.

The defrost selector is great for preparing frozen foods before toasting them. It also comes with a special bun and bagel selector that toasts one side hotter than the other for a perfect finish.

The timer is an easy to use dial turn. The automatic ejection comes with a manual control. There is a high lift mechanism for smaller items. The adjustable rear leg makes the toaster capable of standing flush on an uneven surface.

With all this pedigree it also comes with a removable crumb tray and an extra-wide 28 mm, adjustable, inner wire guard that is designed to accept a sandwich cage.

Here’s what I like:

  • You can control each slot individually
  • Patented heating design / 28 mm adjustable guard 
  • 1.10-inch wide slots
  • Beautiful retro design

The bad sides:

  • The crumb tray is a bit too small

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 14 x 9 x 8 inches
  • Weight: 9.4 pounds
  • Warranty: 1 year
Best Budget
Best Budget Toaster - BLACK+DECKER, Stainless Steel (T4030)

Best Budget Toaster – BLACK+DECKER, Stainless Steel (T4030)

If you’re looking for a 4-slice toaster that is budget friendly, Black+Decker has got a great model for you. It’s a well made, stainless steel toaster for a great price!

The T4030 has extra-wide slots that are made to fit any type of bread, and it includes self-adjusting guides that automatically center the bread inside the slots. 

You can choose between 6 shades, and 3 specific cook modes – toast, bagel, or defrost mode.

Here’s what I like:

  • It’s quite affordable
  • Reliable and durable toaster made of stainless steel
  • Extra-wide 1.5-inch slots

The bad sides:

  • It doesn’t lift thin slices up very well – you may need to fish that pop tart out 

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 12 x 11 x 9 inches
  • Weight: 6.7 pounds
  • Warranty: 1 year
Easy To Use
Best Overall - KitchenAid with Manual High-Lift Lever (Kmt4115cu)

Best Overall – KitchenAid with Manual High-Lift Lever (Kmt4115cu)

This durable all-metal construction 4-slice toaster is a great device for making golden, crispy, bread and bagel slices. You will love it’s basic, yet effective design.

Backed by the well known KitchenAid brand, it comes with a plethora of features, including a high-lift lever for safe toast removal, completion alert delicate beeper (beeps 1 time), a removable crumb tray, cord storage under the device, extra-wide 1.5″ slots, and a cancel function.

Here’s what I like:

  • Automatically adjusting slots that adapt to the thickness of your slice
  • Bagel preset
  • High-quality, durable metal body
  • Extra-wide slots

The bad sides:

  • Doesn’t have a defrost function

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 11.4 x 11.6 x 7.5 inches
  • Weight: 7.2 pounds
  • Warranty: 1 year
Best Commercial-grade
Dualit  4-Slice Design Series (465550)

Dualit 4-Slice Design Series (465550)

The Dualit 46555 may not be the cheapest of the bunch, but it’s sure to last a long time. It’s made with commercial-grade elements, intended for mass use.

This toaster has a handy feature called Peek & Pop, which lets you check out your slice color without having to pause toasting. It’s also quite easy to clean.

The slots of this Dualit model are extra wide and can accommodate a sandwich cage. It also has defrost and bagel settings. 

Here’s what I liked:

  • Commercial grade elements make this model durable
  • Very deep toaster wells
  • Supports a sandwich cage

The bad sides:

  • The toaster is super strong – even lower settings brown significantly

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 11.5 x 11 x 8.1 inches
  • Weight: 7 pounds
  • Warranty: 1 year
Best Basic Model
Sencor Premium, Metallic, High Life Toaster (STS6076GD)

Sencor Premium, Metallic, High Life Toaster (STS6076GD)

A toaster doesn’t only need to make toast – it needs to make your kitchen look amazing as well. This beautiful metallic model by Sencor is just that; and with five color options, you can pick the one that fits your interior design best.

Great news – it’s as durable as it is pretty. With a stainless steel body, it’ll last a long time. The outer case stays cool to the touch because it’s well insulated on the inside. 

The toaster features a large, stylish display, and 9 heat settings with an electronic timer. When it comes to toasting options, it has a bagel setting and an option to defrost your bread before toasting.

Here’s what I liked:

  • Beautiful metallic design
  • Reasonable price
  • 9 heat settings

The bad sides:

  • The buttons control both sides at once – no individual toast controls

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 11.8 x 11 x 9.8 inches
  • Weight: 7.4 pounds
  • Warranty: 2 years
Best Compact
Cuisinart CPT-142P1 2-Slice, Compact Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-142P1 2-Slice, Compact Toaster

The CPT-142 is Cuisinart’s compact model yet it doesn’t fall short of competitors.

Featuring extra-wide slots of 1 ½” each and delivering bread using a high lift carriage. This toaster provides you an extra few inches so you don’t burn your fingers!

The extra-wide slots are perfect for holding thick slices of artisan bread, bagels, and even English muffins and crumpets.

The shading feature allows you to set up to 7 different levels of color to your toast, and it comes with reheat, defrost and cancel settings, as well as a special bagel setting.

This is a dial and push-button interface with cord storage and a useful and easy to slide-open crumb tray.

Here’s what I like:

  • Wide 1.5-inch slots
  • Includes the bagel, defrost, and reheat function
  • Features a neat cord wrap underneath the model

The bad sides:

  • The outside of this toaster is made of plastic

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 10.8 x 10.7 x 7.2 inches
  • Weight: 4.5 pounds
  • Warranty: 3 years
Retro Style
Best Long Slot - Smeg 50's Retro Style 4 Slice Toaster (TSF02RDUS)

Best Long Slot – Smeg 50’s Retro Style 4 Slice Toaster (TSF02RDUS)

If you’re longing for the golden age, and you want to add a bit of retro flair to your kitchen, I highly recommend this stylish model. It was manufactured by Smeg, a high-end appliance brand from Italy. 

This Smeg 4-slice toaster is not only eye-candy, it’s a high-quality toaster with a steel housing and a glamorous powder-coated enamel finish. 

While this toaster only has two slots, both can accommodate 4 slices of bread at a time. The slots are extra-wide at 1.4 inches, and 10 inches long so most types of bread will fit. The slots have a self-centering technology that automatically sets up your slice into the perfect position.

Check out all the best Smeg toasters in our comprehensive review. 

Here’s what I liked:

  • The retro design is absolutely gorgeous
  • Extra-wide 1.4-inch slots
  • Lets you reheat and defrost, and has a bagel setting

The bad sides:

  • Some people complained that it doesn’t toast evenly

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 15.5 x 8.2 x 8.5 inches
  • Weight: 4.5 pounds
  • Warranty: 1 year
Best High-Tech
Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster (CPT-440)

Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster (CPT-440)

The Cuisinart CPT-440 is a leading-edge piece of kitchen technology. This beautifully designed device comes with Cuisinart’s Touch to Toast™ feature, which eliminates levers. This means that you get to press a buton and the toaster does the work for you.

It sports a professional, brushed stainless-steel housing that comes with a blue backlit LED display and an LCD countdown. This model has an integrated enhanced bagel toasting program. The motorized lift is completely controlled with “Cancel”, “Defrost”, and “Re-Heat” options.

The unit comes with 4 extra-wide slots. It’s one of the leading models on the market, and it’s very easy to clean.

Here’s what I liked:

  • Leverless, button-controlled lifting mechanism
  • Pre-made bagel settings
  • Defrost, reheat, and cancel functions

The bad sides:

  • The highest setting is not that high at all – many people claim they need to toast their bread twice, so this is not a great choice if you like your toast dark.

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 11.42 x 10 x 7.75 inches
  • Weight: 6.5 pounds
  • Warranty: 3 years
Great Option
Oster 4-Slice Toaster, Brushed Metal (TSSTTRWF4S-SHP)

Oster 4-Slice Toaster, Brushed Metal (TSSTTRWF4S-SHP)

The Oster is a stylish, brushed stainless steel toaster that comes with four wide slots and seven shade settings. The convenient retractable cord is great. The user-friendly control panel provides you with a high lift lever to raise smaller items making them easier to take out.

There is a seven shade-setting dial, and the control panel provides several push-button selections for choosing between Bagel, Frozen, Pastry, and Cancel.

The 7 toast shade settings will control your light to dark toasting levels, and the anti-jam feature will automatically shut the toaster off. This model also comes with a dishwasher-safe, easy to manage crumb tray.

Here’s what I like:

  • Automatically adjusting bread slots
  • Includes the bagel, pastry, and defrost setting
  • It has a neat retractable cord

The bad sides:

  • The slots are quite small – not ideal for bigger, artisanal bread slices

Specifications:

  • Dimensions (LWH): 12.7 x 13 x 8.5 inches
  • Weight: 6.2 pounds
  • Warranty: 1 year
Toast and jelly for breakfast

How to Choose the Best 4-Slice Toaster

As you can see, there are many different models, but they all come with similar features and functions. Here are some features that you should pay close attention to.

Extra Wide Slots 

Wider slots let you play with artisan bread and allow you to toast every possible product, from a whole bagel to a simple slice of white bread.

Automatic Lifting 

Fully automated lifting mechanisms bring your toast up when it reaches the desired color. This allows the toast slice to cool down a little, and keeps you from burning your fingers trying to get toast out. Most toasters have this feature, but it’s better to be safe than sorry, so check in advance.

Shading Options 

Almost every toaster comes with multiple shading features that are designed to create a yummy finish. Many toasters have control panels that let you pick the heat settings. In turn, this lets you make toast for your friends and family just the way they like it, all in one toaster.

Adjustable Slots 

Quite simply, not everyone in your home may like toast cooked the same way. Adjustable slots solve this problem. The more advanced toasters allow you to control each slot individually, or in a pair. The cheaper toasters may not offer this feature.

Defrosting 

A defrosting function helps prepare your frozen bread slice for toasting, giving you perfect results in the end.

No-Mess 

Toasting bread can be messy. Do yourself a favor and get a toaster with a crumb tray – it’ll help make cleaning so much easier.

Cord Wraps

A device with a designated place to wrap your cord will make sure your toaster is not messy when not in use.

LED Display

An LED panel on your toaster can be quite helpful. The display will show progress and alert you when toasting is complete.

A Durable Build 

Look for models made of high-grade steel and insulated heating elements. They’re built to last.

Reliable Brand

Make sure the model you pick is made by a reliable brand, such as Cuisinart, Kitchenaid, Breville, Dualit, Oster, Smeg, and Hamilton Beach. These are the leading brands, and you can not find anyone beating them when it comes to design, functionality, result, and in some cases, price.

The Bottom Line

The bottom line is this: when choosing the best toaster, you have to decide on the level of intricacy you want or need, and then decide on the design that speaks to you. You want a sturdy toaster that can withstand a lot of use over time and a device that has reliable electronics.

When buying a toaster, you shouldn’t just simply go for the most expensive model. Instead, you can opt for a well-made yet affordable toaster if you take the time to consider design as well as functionality. When it comes to price, you can’t beat the great deals offered at overstock.com. We always recommend taking a look prior to making your purchase!

Finally – we would be remiss if we didn’t mention toaster safety. It’s particularly important to teach your children how to prevent a toaster fire. Please practice basic fire safety and keep your fire extinguisher serviced and close by!

We take great pride in recommending only the best products to our readers. If you found this article informative, please share it using the buttons below, and be sure to leave a comment!

About the author

Donna Djuragic

Donna Djuragic is a crafty blogger who's always on the lookout for ways to make her homestead nicer, better organized, and more functional. She enjoys reading, gardening, home improvement, and finding pragmatic solutions to common homeowner problems. Feel free to get in touch via donna@thehomedweller.com.

P.S. - Donna loves to hear from her readers. Be sure to leave a comment below!

3 Comments

Leave a Comment