Pellet Stove Inserts – Buyer’s Guide!

If you’re wondering what is a pellet stove then this is right where you should be. The pellet stove is a way that you can keep your fireplace but not have to chop logs all the time.

It’s also a great way for you to cover the old fireplace that you’ve had for a long time with something a little more modern. You’ll want to learn how to use a pellet stove and even how does a pellet stove work.

But no matter what else, you’re going to have a great looking stove and a great looking space in your home.

How to Install a Wood-Burning Fireplace Insert | This Old House

YouTube video

List of Top-Rated Pellet Stove Inserts

PhotoProductSpaceTimeDetails
Napoleon EPI-1402MNapoleon EPI-1402M Pellet Stove Insert2,000sq.ft.8hrs.View on Amazon
Timberwolf Economizer InsertTimberwolf Economizer Pellet Stove Insert2,000sq.ft.30hrs.View on Amazon
Breckwell P2000I Pellet InsertBreckwell P2000I Pellet Stove Insert2,000sq.ft.12hrs.View on Amazon
TimberRidge 55-TRPEPI InsertTimberRidge 55-TRPEPI Pellet Stove Insert2,000sq.ft.24hrs.View on Amazon
Drolet DB03122KDrolet DB03122K Pellet Stove Insert500-1,600sq.ft.6hrs.View on Amazon
Vogelzang TR004Vogelzang TR004 Pellet Stove Insert1,800sq.ft.8hrs.View on Amazon
Napoleon TPI35Napoleon TPI35 Pellet Stove Insert2,000sq.ft.30hrs.View on Amazon
Stove Builder International CW2900Stove Builder International CW2900 Pellet Stove Insert2,100sq.ft.8hrs.View on Amazon
Napoleon TimberwolfNapoleon Timberwolf Pellet Stove Insert2,000sq.ft.30hrs.View on Amazon
Comfortbilt HP22iComfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Insert2,800sq.ft.18hrs.View on Amazon

The Best Pellet Stove Inserts Reviews

🥇 Napoleon Fireplaces Wood Burning Fireplace Insert for EPI-1402

Another efficient and durable unit from Napoleon! This elegant heating source brings incredible beauty of nature’s element of fire inside your home. The exterior of this stove is very stylish.

It has everything you need for your comfort – an arched cast iron door that is very easy to open/close, effective air wash to keep the large viewing window clean, and a matching spring handle.

This fireplace insert is designed to be a perfect fit and provide years of excellent service and warmth. It has two powerful and quiet 100 CFM blowers, which allows circulating a lot of heated air.

It makes almost no smoke while starting the fire, burns wood evenly, and is very easy to maintain and use. The only thing you will have to do is to consider the firewood length to fit the insert well and burn effectively.

The recommended fuel size is 16″. The firebox is lined with firebrick to provide years of trouble-free service are guaranteed. They help to retain heat and absorb energy and bring more heat into the room.

Features

  • Heat output – up to 70,000 BTU’s
  • Heating area – up to 2000 sq. ft.
  • Glass size – 10 1/2″h x 16 1/4″w
  • Large Viewing Area
  • Dimensions (with flashing) – 31 1/4″ x 44 1/2″ x 19 3/4″
  • Capacity – 2.25 cubic foot
  • Weight – 185 lbs (with bricks), 110 lbs (without bricks)
  • Fire burning duration – 7 hours (low)
  • Two 100 CFM blowers
  • Adjustable fan speed
  • Black and porcelain black insert finishes
  • Fuel size – 16″
  • EPA Certified

🥇 Timberwolf Economizer Pellet Stove Insert

This isn’t an Avalon pellet stove, but it’s a great option that you won’t want to miss out on. It’s going to give you the pellet stove insert that you’re looking for with a sleek and moderate-sized design to fill in your fireplace.

Heating Abilities

With this fireplace insert you’re going to have a 45 pound hopper capacity. That means all you need to do is fill up the hopper once and the stove will just keep itself going until it runs out. That means you can get up to 30 hours of burn time with one fill.

The efficient burning process helps to get this long period of burning and all of it means you can heat up to 2,000 square feet with no problem. There’s plenty of heating power to this small system, even with one single load.

Overall Features

This pellet insert is smaller than some of the other options, but it’s going to give you the features that you’re looking for.

The surround sits back a little further while the rest of the insert sticks out a bit for a mantle and hearth. You’ll be able to set this up on any fireplace and install it easily.

The best thing about this system is that it has a mix between a slightly older style and a slightly more modern one so you can enjoy the way that your fireplace looks without the need for the chopping wood you did before.

Do I Need to Have a Fireplace to Use This?

This system is designed to go into an existing fireplace. Without the current masonry of a fireplace, there’s no way to properly install it.

Can I Hook This Up To a Digital Remote?

You can set up a control panel and a digital system to control this fireplace however that will require additional work and materials.

This fireplace insert is designed to give you plenty of heat and to make it easy for you to keep the heat coming for a very long time more than an entire day even.

🥇 Breckwell P2000I Pellet Stove Insert

This isn’t a US Stove pellet stove but it’s a great option and one you’re going to love to look at. It has a unique look that is super easy to install and even easier to fill when you’re ready to start heating space around you.

Heating and Abilities

With this system, you’re going to have a hopper that’s able to hold up to 60 pounds. This sounds like a lot and it is. You’re going to fill up the bin and then have plenty of time to get heat for up to 2,000 square feet throughout your home.

This stove can put out a lot of heat quickly and it’s easy to get started because it has an automatic ignition switch. That way you just fill it up and push the button and it’s going to be ready to go in no time at all.

Overall Features

There are plenty of features to this system but it’s the look of it that’s going to keep your attention. The surround and the face are each a beautiful steel gray and the gold accents to the thing are unique in their own right.

You’re going to have a glass opening on three sides rather than just the door at the front. This gives the whole thing a more elegant look and makes sure your fireplace is looking updated. It also has plenty of space to see the burning happening on the inside.

Does This Need Continuous Maintenance?

Regular maintenance and cleaning are going to be important for any stove that you buy, so make sure you clean out ashes and whatever may remain of pellets when you’re done using it each time.

Does This Use a Lot of Pellets?

It does tend to use quite a few pellets when you’re heating your space. This means you may need a little more than with similar systems.

This pellet stove insert is going to give you a great look and it’s going to give you a stylish way to update your current fireplace. There’s no reason for you to have something old fashioned anymore if you don’t want to.

🥇 TimberRidge 55-TRPEPI Pellet Stove Insert

Before you go getting the wood pellets for pellet stove you need to find the right pellet stove to deck out your fireplace. This one is going to be a great pick and it’s going to help you create a beautiful and stylish space in no time at all.

Heating and Controls

When it comes to heating you want a fireplace insert that’s going to give you plenty, right? Well, this one offers you a 45 pound hopper that, when full, can put out heat for up to 24 hours.

You’ll be able to set it up for an entire day without having to load the hopper up again.

What’s great is that this system is designed to heat a space that’s up to 2,000 square feet. That means you won’t have any problems getting your space nice and warm and making sure the entire house feels even better than before.

Additional Features and Setup

When it comes to setting up this system, you’ll have no problems. It’s actually compatible with both masonry fireplaces and zero clearance fireplaces.

On top of that, you get a flue collar to point all the smoke and discharge in the right direction and an outdoor air kit.

In order to operate the system you have a simple control panel that even has a push-button, automatic start. That way you can fill it up and then push it on or off whenever you want.

There’s no reason to spend a lot of time working with an ignition system from a different system.

Does the Surround Come With the Set?

Yes, you’re going to get the surround with the system when you decide to get it. You’ll also get all the pieces to get it installed.

Does This Need an Electrical Connection?

Yes, you will need to have an electrical system installed in the vicinity of the fireplace so you can plug it in for continuous use.

Is This a Quiet System?

It is a very quiet system though you will have some noise as the stove continues to burn pellets and pellets are dropped through the hopper.

This is a stylish and unique system that you’re going to like having, especially if you didn’t have a fireplace before and want to use this in place of a zero-clearance unit. You can get a lot of versatility and options.

🥇 Drolet 60,000 BTU EPA-Certified Escape Fireplace Wood Insert

The Escape 1400 Trio will make your home atmosphere warmer and add some real coziness to your interior. Many owners state it’s really easy and fast to install, and the price is perfect. The unit is highly efficient, and EPA certified.

It has a large viewing window (ceramic glass) for you to enjoy the fire and a blower with adjustable speed to spread the heat of 60.000 BTUs throughout 500-1600+ sq. ft. of your place. Besides, the stove also has a steel interior, 29″ x 44″ faceplate, brick-lined firebox (1.9″), cast iron door, 25-foot liner kit, Vortex flexible stainless steel liner, and a chimney cap.

The fuel type for this model is dry cordwood. Many people who have purchased this stove say the ambiance provided is perfect, and the unit does its job perfectly. You can use pretty wide (20″) pieces of wood for the firebox with no problems and burn them up to 6 hours.

The fan is quiet when working. Create excellent warmth throughout your house that no furnace or heat pump can provide. Heat your place effectively and stay warm!

Features

  • Ceramic glass door
  • Cast iron door
  • Brick-lined firebox
  • Steel interior
  • Air-wash system
  • Blower
  • Surround
  • 25-foot liner kit
  • Vortex flexible stainless steel liner
  • Insert connector
  • Chimney cap (no screen)
  • 29″ x 44″ faceplate
  • Heating area – 500-1,600 sq. ft.
  • Max log length – 20″
  • Weight – 329 lbs
  • Dimensions – 28-3/8″(W) x 23-3/8″(D) and 21″(H)
  • Firebox volume – 1.9 cubic foot
  • Burn time – 6 hours
  • EPA certified

🥇 Vogelzang TR004 Colonial EPA Wood Stove

This insert can burn wood pieces for up to 8 hours (1 fueling) and is very efficient. It puts us up to 69.000 BTUs of heat, which is more than enough to spread heat across 1.800 square feet.

Refit your old fireplace into a high-efficient clean-burning wood stove, which can tremendously improve your experience. This unit includes a heavy cast iron door with a cool-touch spring handle and an air wash glass that allows a fantastic view of the burning fire.

This stove will surely lower your heating bills. This unit features a 150 CFM adjustable speed blower with an automatic on/off state. The tough-plate steel exterior is built for years of performance while the large viewing window brings the beauty of the fire into your home.

Forget about furnaces and overusing electricity! You have a special damper that provides the primary air for your stove and allows adjustment for your specific comfort level. The heating system is a simple and efficient way of heating your home while requiring less maintenance.

The price is really good, better than other “better” quality stoves.

Features

  • Heat output – 69,000 BTUs
  • Heat area – 1.800 sq.ft.
  • Log length – 18″
  • 150 CFM blower (adjustable speed)
  • Cast iron door
  • Faceplate (44″ x 34″)
  • Heavy gauge 3/16″ reinforced plate steel
  • Firebrick lining
  • 14.5″ x 8″ cermaic glass window
  • Dimensions – 24.75″(L) (with blower) x 20″(L) (without blower) x 26.5″(W) x 21.5(H)
  • Weight – 265 lbs
  • EPA certified

🥇 Napoleon TPI35 Pellet Stove Insert

This stove is one of the most stylish ones on the list. Check out the exterior – the name of the brand perfectly fits the unit it produces. Just take a look at its solid black door with air wash!

What’s impressive about this high-quality steel insert is it’s burning time – 30 hours! Can you believe this? Moreover, the heating power is also outstanding – up to 38,250 BTUs, which is perfect for a mobile home.

This unit was designed to burn pellet fuel and heat up to 2000 square feet. But you can also use a corn/wood pellet mixture (50% max. corn). It has a 120 CFM convection fan, digital control panel, heat exchanger, auto ignitor, flashing with black trim, and thermostatic control.

Many owners also state it’s elementary to install (simple installation process) and maintain, provides very little ash and good heat circulation, starts up very fast too. Overall, it’s a reliable quality-built construction for flawless operation and your warmth. Plus, it lowers your electricity bills!

Features

  • 38,250 BTUs of heating power
  • Heating area – 2,000 sq. ft.
  • Flashing with Black Trim
  • Burning time – 30 hours
  • Easy to use and maintain
  • 120 CFM convection fan
  • Thermostatic control
  • 45-pound hopper capacity
  • 76.3% efficiency rating
  • Weight – 140 lbs
  • Min. fireplace opening – 22″(W) x 21″(H)
  • Auto ignitor
  • Heat exchanger
  • Digital control panel
  • Fuel type – pellets
  • Dimensions – 21-1/4″(W) x 20-13/16″(H) x 23-1/2″(D)
  • Surround dimensions – 38-3/8″(W) x 29-3/8″(H)

🥇 Stove Builder International CW2900 Century high-Efficiency Wood Insert

This unit can boast with its high heat output of 75,00 BTUs and a wide heating area (up to 2,100 square feet).

The maximum burn time is 8 hours. It has a ceramic glass door with cast iron frame, premium-quality CFM 130 blower, glass air-wash system, brick-lined firebox for better heat distribution, faceplate kit (32″ x 50″), and stainless-steel secondary-air system.

If you are worried about the smoking issue, don’t be, because you will have no problems with that. Just don’t forget to turn off your blower before you open the door. Open the door slowly and let some of that smoke escape out of the firebox.

This unit has a perfect draft on a cold winter day and, consequently, atmosphere as well as the heat you expect from a high-quality fireplace insert. Take it easy with your first fires though, don’t overstuff the firebox with wood and make a small fire at first.

You are going to be happy with the quality of this unit, the way it works, and the way it fits in! The install is easy, and efficiency is high.

Features

  • Heat output – 75,000 BTUs
  • Heating area – up to 2,100 sq. ft.
  • 2.4 cubic foot firebox
  • Max burn time – 8 hours
  • 32″ x 50″ faceplate kit
  • Dimensions – 28-3/8″(W) x 26-1/8(D) x 23-1/8″(H)
  • Weight – 395 lbs
  • Max log length – 20″
  • Fuel type – dry cordwood
  • Glass air-wash system
  • Brick-lined firebox
  • Stainless-steel secondary-air system
  • EPA certified

🥇 Timberwolf Economizer EPA Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

This stylish fireplace insert has an 86% efficiency rating and is one of the most efficient units on this list, as well as in the industry.

All necessary things for your stable heating and stylish interior look are included – sizeable ceramic glass viewing area, cast iron door, and dual blower system (160 CFM) for increased efficiency.

You can feed up to 18″ (or even longer) logs to the firebox, which can burn them for up to 8 hours at a time. Just make sure you don’t have any coal leftovers in it so that there was room for wood to generate much heat.

Overall, it’s an easy-to-maintain, cost-effective, and reliable fireplace insert designed to provide the most heat and serve you for years.

Features

  • Heat output – 65,000 BTUs
  • Heating area – 2000 sq.ft
  • Blower kit
  • Surround
  • Cast iron door
  • Dual Blower System 160 CFM
  • Fuel type – hardwood logs (18″)
  • 1.9 cu. ft. firebox capacity
  • 5-piece flashing
  • Weight – 291 lbs
  • Dimensions – 14″ x 25.9″ x 22″
  • EPA certified

🥇 Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove/Fireplace Insert 42,000 Btu

Now, this high-efficient heater over here looks more like a real fire chamber to burn all your evil thoughts (or your enemies!). Check out the design of the viewing window! Now, that’s a unique easy-to-clean heavy gauge exterior.

What’s even easier is using this stove – you just push the power button and watch it light itself! The stove comes with step-by-step instructions for an easy installation. You just have to place it in your fireplace and install your exhaust pipe through your chimney and a cap on your roof.

Fill the firebox with pellets and start the fire – your home will become warm before you know it. It’s an energy-efficient choice, as well as a beautiful atmospheric addition to your interior. Did you know that when you look at the fire, you burn your evil thoughts? Feels like you can look at it forever because the flame is just fascinating.

It attracts the eye, inspires calmness, and deep thoughtfulness. The outside world seems to go somewhere at some point when you realize that what is happening inside you is more attractive as you immerse yourself deeper into your inner world.

This model from Comfortbilt provides 50,000 BTUs of power to spread throughout 2000 square feet. It has a 47 lbs hooper, auto ignition, and programmable heat settings.

Features

  • Heat power – 50,000 BTUs
  • Heating area – up to 2800 sq. ft.
  • Burning hours – up to 18 hours
  • 47 lbs hooper
  • Programmable heat settings
  • Easy-to-clean exterior
  • Autoignition
  • Large viewing area
  • Bay design
  • EPA and CSA ertified
  • Rear mounted 3” standard exhaust port
  • 2” standard air intake
  • Finishing cover shroud is 42”(W) and 33”(H)

Conclusion

When you decide to put in a pellet stove vs. wood stove, you’re going to have a much simpler process of keeping that stove going. You’re also going to have an easy time getting your stove to give off the right amount of heat throughout the house.

It’s a great way to make some great upgrades and you’ll be able to get that pellet stove insert installation done a lot faster than you might think. The only thing you’ll need to decide is which one of these pellet stove inserts is the one for you. You might find it hard to choose.

About the author

Jessica Nickson

Jessica Nickson

Jessica Nickson is a keen home and garden innovator with over 25 years of hands-on experience in, home improvement, landscape gardening and all things appliance related to making life easier and more interesting. You can contact her via e-mail - jessica@thehomedweller.com.

Leave a Comment